Warning: this post is for people who like to geek out over pizza.
The sign said “Welcome To Conneticut- Pizza Capital Of The World”.
Really? Connecticut is the pizza capital? That seemed like a bold statement considering we had just spent the day in New York City.
When we got to our hotel and checked in just outside of New Haven, I started looking into the state’s ridiculous claim of being a pizza mecca. Turns out, there was good reason for the boast. (The internet also mentioned New Haven as hosting the diner that invented the hamburger- more on that later.)
The state’s “pizza king” hopes appeared to rest on several establishments sprinkled throughout the city of New Haven, most notably Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana, Modern Apizza and Sally’s Apizza.
Since we were in New Haven for the day, and since I’m always looking for great pizza, we decided to check things out and put the state’s bragging to the test. My father in law often tells the story of visiting Pepe’s years ago, and says it was the best pizza he ever had in his life. So off to Pepe’s we went.

We parked downtown and walked about a mile through the city, into the section called Little Italy (also known as Rooster Square). We walked right past Sally’s Apizza and down the street a block to Pepe’s, where the line outside had already formed. Sal “Sally” Consiglio opened his place down the street from his uncle Frank Pepe in 1938, after working in his uncle’s shop for a time. Pepe’s opened in 1925. So the pizza royalty of the pizza capital exists all one block of Wooster Street.
As we walked through the restaurant to our table, our view was dominated by the massive, coal fired oven. It took up most of the wall and was filled with what looked like countless pizzas. The oven is as old as the pizzeria; in fact some might say that the oven is the pizzeria. According to Pepe’s website, the extra dry air created by the coal fired oven interacts with Pepe’s wetter than normal dough recipe, creating crust with a much richer flavor than other recipes.


Pepe’s does not sell slices; it’s whole pies only. So we made our choice of 2 pizzas and prepared to overeat. We ordered an extra pepperoni, and one of the famous tomato pies.
As we waited for them to come out, we took a look at the family and business histories, told in a series of pictures hanging on the walls all around the place. I thought I saw our manager in one of the family shots right above our booth.

The square tray arrived and we started the taste test. Pepe’s was as advertised and excellent! The crust was paper thin yet stout enough not to crumble under the weight of the slice. The website was right, the crust did have a richer flavor to it; a noticeable cut above the typical, bland bread of most pizza. The coal oven had the crust perfectly crispy without being burned. Everything on top of the pie tasted fresh and well blended. The sauce and cheese flavors just seemed deeper than usual. The pepperoni tasted like little slices of actual meat.

I have to be honest and say that I expected Pepe’s to be great, but not noticeably better than the other “best pizzas” I’ve had in my life- but I was wrong. I agree with my father-in-law, Pepe’s was the best pizza I’ve ever had.
I was especially interested in tasting the tomato pie. I had heard of them and knew that they were popular in some places, but had never had one. Apparently, the tomato pie is what launched Frank Pepe’s business back in 1925.
The tomato pie is made only with tomatoes/sauce imported from the Naples area of Italy, Pecorino Romano cheese from Sardinia, olive oil and garlic. That’s it.
When some people hear this they get all beside themselves because there’s no mozzarella on the pie, but I can guarantee you- that type of cheese is not necessary. The tomato pie is phenomenal!
To me, it’s the romano that puts it over the top. As good as the pepperoni pizza was, the tomato pie was better- much better! If I could get a tomato pie like that where I live, I would probably just stop eating regular pizza. Seriously.

We stayed at Pepe’s for quite a while, trying to finish up the equivalent of one pizza per person. The funny thing is, for as much as we ate, we didn’t get the familiar bloating that usually comes with eating too much, especially too much bread. I’ve heard that in Europe, the food is made with better quality ingredients and that bread doesn’t cause bloating over there. Maybe Pepe’s old school style and European ingredients enable it to avoid those typical American pitfalls. At any rate, we felt better than we should have after eating such a large lunch.
If you are ever in New Haven, or in Connecticut near Pepe’s other locations, definitely get to Pepe’s. You may learn why, as ridiculous as it sounded to me at first, Connecticut really might be the pizza capital of the world.

I used to work for Amore Pizza and was famous as a pizza girl in the area. I made pizzas and calzones from scratch, okay we made as a team all the delicious food. My customers tipped me like crazy, it was back in Denver, Colorado. The best day for tips was when Broncos won the super bowl, I can still remember the happiness in the air … Good old days
LikeLiked by 1 person
Awesome! I used to work at a popular sandwich/sub shop is my hometown and it was one of the best jobs I’ve ever had!
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s cool, I can’t say the same about my pizza job but it had some good days and fun ppl
LikeLiked by 1 person
Been to Pepe’s! It’s fantastic! Sent from the all new AOL app for iOS
LikeLiked by 1 person
I totally agree – thanks for reading Dave!
LikeLike
Despite I have never heard of Tomato Pie, it looks delicious !
LikeLiked by 1 person
It was excellent! I think it was the romano that really made it great. Thanks for reading!
LikeLike
Pizza geek? Right here, at your service! That tomato pie looks SOOOOOO good! And yah…a little pecorino romano and boom! Heaven in pizza form. Yum and yum! 😜❤️😜
LikeLiked by 1 person
I was not aware that pecorino Romano even existed but wow -that stuff is great!🤩
💚
LikeLiked by 1 person
Isn’t it tho?!? Great on a bowl of minestrone, too! 😋❤️😋
LikeLiked by 1 person
Are you saying they have it the grocery store? I figured it was restaurant only😲
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yep! In the fancy cheese section…waiting for ya! 😎❤️😎
LikeLike